Definition
A dissenting opinion is written by one or more judges who would decide the case differently from the majority.
Political Dictionary
Dissenting Opinion
A dissenting opinion disagrees with the court’s judgment.
Why It Matters
Dissents record alternative reasoning, criticize the majority, and may influence later courts, lawmakers, or public debate.
How It Works
A dissenting judge explains why the majority’s legal or factual analysis is wrong.
History
Notable dissents have sometimes shaped later legal change.
Example
A justice may argue that the majority interpreted a constitutional right too narrowly.
Common Misconceptions
- A dissent changes the outcome.
- Dissents are binding precedent.
- A dissent is evidence that the decision is invalid.
Related Terms
Related Topics
See Also